- Fortune Street: A rare, complex Monopoly-style game featuring Mario and Square characters. Used copies go for $40+, new for $120+.
- Mario Party 9: The final Mario Party game on Wii, sought after by collectors. Used copies average $70, new copies go for $140+.
- The Last Story: A JRPG exclusive to Wii, priced at $90+ for used copies and $100+ for new ones. Fan of Final Fantasy may enjoy this.
The Nintendo Wii holds a unique place in gaming history, celebrated as a groundbreaking console that defied expectations. At a time when the PlayStation 2 and Xbox dominated the market without the need for motion controls—except for fleeting trends like the EyeToy and Kinect—Nintendo took a bold gamble by making motion-based gameplay its defining feature. This daring choice proved to be a massive success.
Over the years, the Wii saw the release of hundreds of titles, with some continuing to launch even into the 2020s. As a result, a number of these games have become exceptionally rare. Whether due to limited production, niche appeal, or less-than-stellar reception, certain Wii titles have become elusive treasures, sought after by passionate collectors and preservationists. Let’s quickly dive in the rare wii games and assess their net worth by order of lowest to highest.
Fortune Street
You’ll Be Needing A Fortune To Play It, Too
- Used: $40+
- New: $120+
Fortune Street is a little-known, experimental game that many have forgotten. It was part of Square Enix’s Itadaki Street series, which had never been released outside of Japan until this title. The game brings together beloved characters from the Mario franchise with those from Square Enix’s Dragon Quest and Final Fantasy series, creating a complex board game experience reminiscent of Monopoly.
The unusual premise—imagine Bowser joining forces with characters like Kiryl and Yangus—along with a likely lack of interest in playing a detailed board game in digital form, led to modest sales, making the game rare today. If you’re fortunate, you might find a used copy for $30 to $40, but if you’re after a new or sealed version, expect to spend close to $200.
Mario Party 9
The Last Party Of Its Generation
- Used: $55+
- New: $140+
Released on the Nintendo Wii in 2012, Mario Party 9 was the last Mario Party title—and indeed, the last Mario game of any kind—to debut on the console. This fact has made it a sought-after collector’s item, with used copies typically selling for around $70.
While it’s easier to find a copy compared to some other rare titles, you’ll still need to budget for it if you’re looking to purchase one online. Though not a mainline Mario title, Mario Party 9 delivers the familiar fun of navigating a virtual board and competing in a variety of minigames with iconic characters.
The Last Story
It’ll Cost You Your Last Buck
- Used: $90+
- New: $100+
If you’re a Final Fantasy fan, this game might catch your eye. It’s a JRPG exclusive to the Wii, created by Final Fantasy mastermind Hironobu Sakaguchi. While the collector’s edition is particularly rare, even standard copies of the game tend to be quite pricey.
Set on the fictional Lazulis Island, the game follows the adventures of a character named Zael, who embarks on quests and battles alongside a party of companions. Interestingly, unlike many Wii titles, this game doesn’t rely on motion controls, making it a bit more accessible—and as unique as it is rare.
Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn
In Case The Fifty Other Fire Emblems Aren’t Quite Enough
- Used: $130+
- New: $250+
Radiant Dawn is one of the most well-known “rare games” and is just as challenging to find as it is to play. Although the Fire Emblem series enjoys widespread popularity today, it originally catered to a more niche audience when it was released.
Due to this limited appeal at the time, both Radiant Dawn and its predecessor, Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance, had a restricted print run. As the series’ fanbase has grown, those looking to revisit these classic titles might be discouraged by the steep prices they now command.
Dokapon Kingdom
Not To Be Confused With That Other Series
- Used: $74+
- New: $250+
At first glance, Dokapon Kingdom might seem like a straightforward board game and RPG hybrid, but it has gained a notorious reputation as a rare and pricey title. Published by Atlus on the Nintendo Wii, the game’s scarcity can likely be attributed to Atlus’ tendency for low print runs.
Interestingly, even though a different publisher handled Dokapon Kingdom’s release on the PlayStation 2, the prices for that version are also surprisingly high, possibly driven by the intense demand for the Wii edition.
My Horse And Me: Riding For Gold
Looks Like Shovelware On The Shelf, Actually Worth A Truckload
- Used: $75+
This game is a must-have for true horse enthusiasts. It stands out as the only title officially licensed by the Fédération Equestre Internationale, a testament to its quality. My Horse and Me follows a familiar formula, focusing on equestrian competitions rather than just bonding with your horse.
Although the game isn’t overly expensive, it remains quite rare. It’s puzzling why it didn’t achieve greater success—though perhaps the lifeless expressions of both the horse and rider on the cover didn’t do it any favors.
Xenoblade Chronicles
Feel The Power Of The Monado; And Cold Hard Cash
- Used: $25+
- Used: $60
Xenoblade Chronicles has long been known as a rare gem, though re-releases on the Nintendo DS and Switch have made it more accessible. Originally, however, getting your hands on this game could cost you—up to $150 for a sealed copy!
Despite its initial scarcity in the West, Xenoblade Chronicles proved popular enough to inspire sequels and a brilliant remaster, which we’re thankful for. There was a time when its future seemed uncertain, but Nintendo’s commitment to the series has certainly paid off!
Guilty Gear XX Accent Core Plus
With A Title Like That, You Know It’s Expensive
- Used: $76+
- New: $130+
Though this entry in the Guilty Gear series is available in various versions across multiple consoles, the Nintendo Wii edition is predictably the most elusive—and carries the highest price tag. This game is an enhanced version of Guilty Gear X2.
While other versions were well-received, the Wii edition suffered from poor controls, which likely impacted its reviews. This may have contributed to the game’s current rarity.
Walk It Out
Burn Calories While You Burn Funds
- Used: $12+
- New: $36+
The Wii became famous for its abundance of fitness games, with Wii Sports often included with the console. Walk it Out is one of those titles, focusing on—you guessed it—walking. Essentially a rhythm game for those who prefer a slower pace, Walk it Out would have been perfect during the pandemic when even a simple walk in the park felt like a luxury, and virtual walking tours became popular. Today, though, Walk it Out stands as a quirky, charming game that’s become somewhat difficult to track down.
Cyberbike Cycling Sports
A ‘Cyberbike’ Sounds Cooler Than It Actually Is
- Used: $200+
- New: $465+
This title is certainly an oddity—while the high prices mentioned apply to the NTSC version, you can easily find a PAL version for under $10. The inflated price seems to stem from the game’s incredibly low sales, which makes it almost amusing that such a niche game, even with the Cyberbike accessory, commands such a high cost.
Nintendo has made significant strides with its fitness-focused peripherals, and this one would have been a great option during the pandemic. If cycling outside wasn’t possible, this game could have provided the next best thing: a virtual outdoor biking experience.
One Piece: Unlimited Adventure
Worth More Than The One Piece Itself
- Used: $35+
- New: $140+
Unlimited Adventure, apparently the first One Piece video game to make its way to Western audiences, offers the typical anime adaptation experience where you can play as your favorite characters, exploring familiar locations and having a good time. Being a Wii title, though, you can expect the usual complex motion controls for interactions.
Although the game is relatively affordable now, finding a copy is no easy task. The game struggled with poor sales, and a glance at its Wikipedia page suggests this might be due to a complete lack of advertising or promotion.
The Oregon Trail 40th Anniversary Edition
You Have Died Of Typhoid, And Bankruptcy
- Used: $50+
- New: $100+
In honor of its 40th anniversary, The Oregon Trail was released on the Wii in 2011, featuring redesigned gameplay and 3D graphics. This version allowed players to not only drive the wagon but also customize the tarp color and even go fishing. Although this classic game received another remake in 2022, the Wii version remains much harder to come by.
Used copies on Amazon can exceed $100, but this edition offers a unique Oregon Trail experience unlike any other platform version, which is reflected in its price.
Metroid Prime Trilogy: Collector’s Edition
Samus Would Need To Sell Her Suit For This
- Used: $120+
- New: $250+
Despite being part of a beloved series and receiving critical acclaim, the Metroid Prime Trilogy is unusual in its extremely limited print run. Why production was halted remains a mystery, but it’s certainly something that weighs on the minds of collectors, especially with renewed interest following the release of Metroid Prime: Remastered and the long-anticipated arrival of Metroid Prime 4: Beyond.
The allure of the game is further heightened by the collector’s edition, which included an art book and a steelbook case. While you can still find copies online, don’t expect to pay a reasonable price for it.
American Mensa Academy
Doesn’t Take A Genius To Know It’s Overpriced
- Used: $150+
- New: $290+
The ‘brain trainer’ genre found great success on Nintendo’s handheld consoles, with Dr. Kawashima’s Brain Training becoming a standout title on the DS. This success inspired many imitators looking to cash in on the trend.
When the genre shifted to the Nintendo Wii, however, it didn’t fare as well. American Mensa Academy is one such example—its lackluster performance has made it a curious collector’s item today. Much like Cyberbike Cycling Sports, the steep price increase seems to apply only to the NTSC version, while PAL versions remain incredibly affordable.
Rhythm Heaven Fever
Inexplicably Called ‘Beat The Beat’ In European Territories
- Used: $129+
- New: $158+
While the Wii U version of Rhythm Heaven Fever was available for a modest $19.99 as a digital download (if you snagged it before the eShop closure), the original Wii release from 2012 tells a different tale. This mini-game-packed title has faded into obscurity, and its rarity has driven up the price.
However, Japanese versions of the game are a bit more affordable, offering a viable option for Wii owners eager to dive into this rhythm game—if they’re out there. And let’s be real: Monkey Watch is an absolute banger.
Ju-on: The Grudge
The Only Grudge You’ll Bear Is Against The Second-Hand Market
- Used: $80+
- New: $200+
Marketed as a “Haunted House Simulator,” this survival horror game was released to commemorate the 10th anniversary of the original Japanese horror franchise that inspired it. You might be more familiar with the Western remake, The Grudge, starring Sarah Michelle Gellar, which first hit theaters in 2004.
The game didn’t achieve much commercial success, but it has become a prized possession among Wii game collectors, with prices rarely falling below $100 for the disc alone. If you’re after the manual and box as well, be prepared to spend even more.
Silent Hill: Shattered Memories
Hopefully Your Copy Won’t Be Shattered
- Used: $100+
- New: $500 – $700 (Sealed And Graded)
Silent Hill games are a rare sight on Nintendo consoles, but 2009’s Shattered Memories marked the series’ debut on the Wii. It quickly became one of the console’s standout horror titles, crafted by Sam Barlow, who later gained recognition for FMV mystery games like Her Story, Telling Lies, and Immortality.
The story loosely follows the plot of the original 1999 game, with Harry Mason searching for his daughter in the eerie town of Silent Hill, while introducing fresh gameplay elements, especially through the use of motion controls. This unique reimagining of Silent Hill is now incredibly hard to find, with new copies fetching high prices.
Shakedown: Hawaii
And ‘Shakedown’ Is The Right Term, Too
- Used: Price Unknown
- PAL New: $80+
In a surprising move, Vblank Entertainment decided to release Shakedown: Hawaii on the Wii in 2020—despite the console being discontinued since 2013. They also launched the game on several other defunct consoles, clearly aiming to appeal to collectors; and why not? It worked for Ubisoft with their endless Just Dance sequels.
Only 3,000 copies of the Wii version were produced, all for the PAL region, as Nintendo of America couldn’t authorize a U.S. release. This has made the game incredibly rare, with even the Wii U version fetching around $120 from collectors.
Club Penguin: Game Day! Limited Edition
Relive Some Puffle-Tinted Nostalgia
- Used: Price Unknown
- New: $750 – $1,000+
As mentioned earlier, the Wii was known for its abundance of sports activity games that made extensive use of the Wiimote and other accessories. Among these were licensed titles like Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Games and this particular Club Penguin game, based on the beloved kids’ MMORPG. While the original Club Penguin: Game Day for Wii is still relatively easy and inexpensive to find, this version is a different story.
This limited edition is distinguished mainly by its cover art, featuring a black Wii logo instead of the usual white, and a jacket design with green, red, yellow, and blue penguin avatars arranged in a triangular pattern. It’s an extremely rare edition, with prices soaring over $1,000. This rarity is due to the fact that it was a staff-exclusive release for the game’s 5th anniversary, making it incredibly hard to find—so much so that even the EPF would have trouble tracking one down.
Sukeban Shachou Rena
Which Roughly Translates To ‘President Cat Rena’
- Used: Price Unknown
- New: $1,300
This game might just be the rarest Wii release ever. It performed abysmally, selling fewer than 100 copies in its first week (unbelievable—how could anyone resist that cover?!). It’s almost impossible to find online, with the only available price tag being over $1,000 for a new copy, and apparently no used copies to be found.
The game itself was an action-packed adventure where you completed minigames to appease a cat named Rena, who also happens to be the CEO of a company. Odd concept? Sure, but we’ve seen stranger ones. And let’s be honest, games featuring cats are always a hit, whether you’re petting them or playing as one, as shown by recent titles like Stray and Little Kitty: Big City. We just can’t get enough of our feline friends, can we?
